Study Finds Disturbing Conclusion About ‘Revenge Porn’ But Experts Are Dubious – DrZhana

Zhana@DrZhana.com

send me an email

Study Finds Disturbing Conclusion About ‘Revenge Porn’ But Experts Are Dubious

Gizmodo recently reached out to me to comment on a new study that claims that 99% of people approve of revenge porn.

For anyone who doesn’t know, revenge porn is posting intimate photos of other people online without their consent, as retaliation against them for hurting you. This can obviously be very damaging for many people; the publishing of sexy or nude pictures has ruined many people’s careers. Yet, according to this study, virtually all of its 100 respondents (most of whom women), “expressed at least some approval (e.g. did not feel remorse) of revenge porn”. 

As you can read in the Gizmodo article, several scholars, myself included had serious methodological issues with this study and their conclusion. Here, I dig deeper into the science behind this study to figure out what exactly is going on here.

Fortunately for humanity (and unfortunately for the revenge porn posters), this claim is highly misleading of what the study actually found.

First, the authors didn’t actually measure “approval” of revenge porn; approval is about attitudes, something you’d measure by asking people about whether they found revenge porn morally acceptable or something like that. Instead, the authors measured people’s anticipated negative emotional reactions to revenge porn, specifically asked them how much blame, anger, and regret they would feel in response to imaginary revenge porn scenarios. Then they reverse scored people’s ratings and called it approval. Not good.

But this is where it gets really bad. (I apologize for the statistics-heavy paragraph, but understanding how the “approval” scale was constructed is key to understanding what’s so misleading about this). Each of the three emotional reactions to 5 separate imaginary scenarios of revenge porn was measured on a 5-point scale of 1-Not at all to 5-Very much. These were then summed together in a scale ranging from 15 to 75, with 75 meaning the person said they would feel “very regretful”, AND “very guilty”, AND “very angry” in all 5 scenarios, and 15 meaning they wouldn’t feel any of these emotions “at all” in all 5 scenarios. So, the authors claim that “99% of participants expressed at least some approval of the revenge porn being committed in the scenarios” was based on the number of participants who scored something lower than 75 on this scale. But that’s just not true! What is true is that 99% of participants felt something other than extreme anger AND blame AND regret to ALL 5 imaginary revenge porn scenarios.

And this actually tells us VERY LITTLE about how the sample as a whole felt about this issue. Because while yes, only 1 person may have felt the extreme level of all three negative emotions in all five scenarios, it’s highly possible (and I’d venture to guess, highly probable) that most people’s overall reactions were still pretty negative, like a 4 or a 5 on the three emotions across the 5 scenarios. In other words, the average level of distress may still have been pretty high, like a 4.5 on that 5-point scale, but you’d never know that from the way the data were presented by the participants. And the kind of information that we’d need to make any real sense of where the sample lies on this scale — the means and the standard deviations for this scale — are notably absent from the paper.

Revenge porn is a fascinating topic with very little research in terms of motivations, outcomes, and people’s perceptions of it. I really hope that we’ll see more studies of this topic (and many others!) with better methods in the future.

Comments

comments

Related Posts

  • A Woman’s Brain During Orgasm: TSOS Podcast Ep. 8!

    What is really going on in the female brain before, during, and after an orgasm? This week on The Science of Sex, Joe and I talk to Dr. Nan Wise, a licensed psychotherapist, cognitive neuroscientist, certified sex therapist, board certified clinical hypnotherapist, and certified relationship specialist with three decades of experience. Her research at Rutgers University has addressed gaps in the scientific literature regarding the neural basis of human sexuality, and has as a result, garnered international attention. This fall, Dr. Wise published a study in the Journal of Sexual Medicine that disputed past research of brain scans of women during orgasm.

  • There’s Growing Evidence For A Link Between Gender Dysphoria And Autism Spectrum Disorders

    We might have reason to believe that there is a connection between Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and gender dysphoria, according to science. This possible link was first brought to light in the 1980’s when a study noted that 10% of the participants, all of whom had been diagnosed with ASD, had trouble answering a question regarding their personal gender identity. Since 2010, at least nine large scale studies have been conducted regarding this subject matter and found that traits of autism were prevalent in 5%-54% of those with gender dysphoria. Several different hypotheses have been proposed to explain the heightened link

  • All About Asexuality: TSOS Podcast Ep. 7!

    We often talk about issues regarding the gay, lesbian, and bisexual communities, but what about those who identify as asexual? On the latest episode of The Science of Sex, Joe and I dove into an interesting yet rarely discussed topic of conversation all about asexuality and its relationship to mental health. Our guest on the show was Lara Greaves, a student in her last month of a PhD in the School of Psychology at the University of Auckland, New Zealand. Her research is broadly in the area of social psychology and includes everything from indigenous voter turnout to the psychological recovery

Get on my list and get free, instant access to three key questions you should ask yourself before trying out an open relationship!

Free Access

FACEBOOK

Do gentlemen really prefer #blondes? A new #evopsych study with a sample of 110 male undergraduates (87% white) sought to find out. Results showed that hair color and to a lesser extent length *do* affect perceptions of personal characteristics. Specifically, lighter hair (#blond and #brunette) was associated with perceptions of #youth, #health and #attractiveness to a greater extent than was black hair, and generally led to more positive perceptions of relationship and parenting potential. The findings for hair length were somewhat less consistent, but they generally suggested that longer hair was associated with youth, enhanced relationship potential, perceptions of #promiscuity and somewhat diminished perceptions of parenting potential. The takeaway? For men, women’s hair can serve as a cue to desired relationship and parenting characteristics.
#evolutionarypsychology #legitsexscience #sexscience #sexresearch #sexsciencenews
link to study: ow.ly/dSQv30gmJ1I
... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook