STI Reality Check: Swine Flu is Worse than Chlamydia! – DrZhana

send me an email

STI Reality Check: Swine Flu is Worse than Chlamydia!

STI Stigma Instagram

Instagram @DrZhana

A guy once told me he’d rather get hit by a car than get oral herpes. Thinking rationally, that makes absolutely no sense. A car hit can kill you or permanently injure you, affecting dramatically your quality of life. Oral herpes–the virus that causes cold sores on the lips–is something that over 60% of the U.S. population has. Aside from being annoying, itchy, and a bit painful for a few days when you have an outbreak, oral herpes really doesn’t affect your life that much. But when it comes to STIs, we’re not thinking rationally. Our fears, instilled in us by systematic and pervasive sex negative culture, overpowers our rationality.

We live in a world that stigmatize sexually transmitted infections (STI) far beyond the severity of the physical health consequences they lead to. Sure, they are unpleasant and inconvenient, and some can have serious long-term effects, but so do many other communicable diseases. Yet no one seems to think that you’re dirty or disgusting or irresponsible or risky if you have or you transmit to someone, say, tuberculosis or the flu. But mention something that’s sexually transmitted, and those labels will get slapped on you in no time.

A study just published in the International Journal of Sexual health provides a striking example of how completely disproportionate the stigma we attach to STIs is in relation to the severity of their actual outcomes. A group of 400 online volunteers (average age = 30) were asked to imagine one of two scenarios. Scenario one: Sarah is going to a party and she noticed some symptoms but disregarded them as another urinary tract infection. She had unprotected sex with a guy and it turned out she had Chlamydia that also got transmitted to him. He had to go to the doctor and take a week of antibiotics. Scenario two: Sarah felt kind of under the weather before going to the party. She dismissed her symptoms as allergies, had unprotected sex with a guy and ended up giving him swine flu (H1N1). He got so sick that he died from it.

partyHow selfish, how dumb, and how risky is Sarah, participants were asked. Guess what? Sarah was rated as more selfish, more risky, and dumber when she transmitted chlamydia to her partner even when it explicitly stated he had to go and get one week of antibiotics than when she gave swine flu to her partner and he died from swine flu.

Please note that in both cases Sarah didn’t realize she had these diseases (thought from the symptoms she had were due to a noncommunicable issue), and the infection got transmitted while she engaged in the exact same risky activity – unprotected sex with someone she didn’t know well. Yet something that led to another person’s death was perceived as less problematic than something that led to a week of Z-pack.

We also just fear that STIs are so much more prevalent and easy to catch than they actually are. In a second experiment reported in this study, about 600 volunteers were asked how many people out of a thousand are going to die: a) in a car crash while driving from Chicago to Detroit (a 300-mile drive) versus b) from AIDS after having unprotected sex one time with someone who was a non-intravenous drug user? thought the risk of dying from AIDS after a single unprotected sexual encounter was much higher than the risk of dying in a car crash on a 300 mile drive (from Chicago to Detroit). In reality, it’s the other way around. This is why we need real sex education and not shaming.

People estimated that an average of 4 people out of 1000 would die in a car crash compared to 17 people out of 1000 would die of AIDS. That’s a huge difference. In reality, far less than 1 in a 1000 would die in either case – so people wildly overestimated the risk of both events. But people in particular overestimated dying of AIDS. In reality, the numbers are reversed: You’re about 20 times more likely to die in a car crash on a 300-mile drive (about 1 in 500,000) than you are to die of AIDS after having unprotected sex once (about 1 in 10 million).

How is that possible? Well, consider these numbers. First, only about 1 in 300 people in the US have HIV. Next, HIV is actually pretty difficult to transmit: about 1 in 1000 will get HIV when having vaginal sex with someone who is HIV positive (anal sex is more risky, about 1 in 300). Finally, current anti-retroviral medications treat HIV+ people to prevent AIDS, making it relatively unlikely that you would die of AIDS even if you are HIV+. Running into someone who’s HIV+, then actually getting the virus, then actually getting sick enough to die from the virus is just really really unlikely.

car crashOur ideas of risks are incredibly inflated. Our ideas of STI risk even more so. Again, it comes down to social stigma and irrational fears.

Please don’t get me wrong: STIs are no fun and you should take as many precautions as you feel are necessary to protect yourself from them. Just like you would protect yourself against the flu or any other communicable diseases. But I think we could all collectively benefit from chilling out about STIs and how scary they are. Demonizing these infections and falsely scaring people into prevention–by inflating risks or making people feel guilty and dirty for having an STI–is counterproductive: It makes it more difficult for people to get tested and have honest conversations about these things.



Related Posts

  • One In Seven Americans Has Had A Threesome And One In Five Finds Them Appealing

    Threesomes get held up as the typical male fantasy fairly often in media. But, what does the research suggest about who actually shares this fantasy, and how many people are actually having threesomes? Luckily, a new study just came out about this exact topic (and more!): With a new study published by Debbie Herbenick and colleagues in the journal PLOS ONE that uses a nationally representative sample of over 2,000 U.S. adults aged 18+, we no longer have to live in the dark when it comes to the prevalence and the appeal of 30+ different sexual behaviors, everything from wearing sexy lingerie to

  • Study Finds Disturbing Conclusion About ‘Revenge Porn’ But Experts Are Dubious

    Gizmodo recently reached out to me to comment on a new study that claims that 99% of people approve of revenge porn. For anyone who doesn’t know, revenge porn is posting intimate photos of other people online without their consent, as retaliation against them for hurting you. This can obviously be very damaging for many people; the publishing of sexy or nude pictures has ruined many people’s careers. Yet, according to this study, virtually all of its 100 respondents (most of whom women), “expressed at least some approval (e.g. did not feel remorse) of revenge porn”.  As you can read in the Gizmodo article, several scholars, myself

Get on my list and get free, instant access to three key questions you should ask yourself before trying out an open relationship!

Free Access


Why do ppl swipe right (or left) on #tinder? #HotOrNot Via Science of Rels. ... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook

What types of relationships are Americans having? A new study on Americans’ sexual #diversity sought to find out. As part of this study, researchers asked 1,420 partnered participants to indicate whether that #relationship was—during the past year—entirely #monogamous, monogamous but sexless, supposedly monogamous, an #openrelationship; or whether they had not discussed their relationship structure. In thinking about the past year, most of the participants reported being entirely monogamous (78%). More than 1 in 10 partnered respondents were currently in monogamous but sexless relationships (12%). Additionally, 4% were supposedly monogamous, 1.6% reported being in an open relationship, 2.5% had not discussed their relationship structure, and the remaining 1.4% identified their relationship in some other way. The takeaway? Despite growing representations in mainstream media of open relationships, the vast majority Americans are still wedded (pun intended) to #monogamy.
#relationshipresearch #legitsexscience #sexscience #sexresearch #sexsciencenews
Link to study:
... See MoreSee Less

View on Facebook